Cviha's random poll (which one is sadder)

#1



and #2

i'd say #2..
#1 aint bad at all, in terms of voice quality, the english version is without a shadow of a doubt, better.. but in japanese.. it just gave me goosebumps.. just like the first time i heard "Cherish - Ai Otsuka" from the "Draw with me" vid.. i cried snot&goo first time i saw that damn vid TT~TT

if you played the disgaea 1st one (hour of darkness) or watched the anime (11th ep) you would've definitely cried because the context of where the song is played strengthens the song (AKA makes you cry phaster)

try hearing the "Natsuhiboshi" from a Naruto ep.. now THAT is SAD..

hard to say which one is sadder--